My favorite analogy for stocks vs the economy

from a new interview I did with NPR this week:

BROWN: And I’m now going to give you my favorite analogy. So a woman is walking through Central Park, and she’s got a dog. What’s a very active kind of dog?

VANEK SMITH: Oh, like a Jack Russell terrier or something like that?

BROWN: Fine. Jack Russell Terrier is great. If you just looked at her, what is she doing? She’s taking normal steps. She’s going in a straight line. She’s walking, you know, upright at a moderate pace – nothing terribly exciting. Then let your eyes pan down a little bit. Look at the dog. The dog is going crazy. It’s chasing birds. It’s digging up clumps of mud. It’s running at trees. It’s peeing all over the place. The dog is the stock market. The woman is the economy. The dog is chasing butterflies, then it’s sniffing itself, you know. So if you’re just watching the dog, you’re not watching the economy. You’re watching the manifestation of hundreds of millions of people’s greed and fear with buying and selling. But you’re not watching an actual representation of how the economy’s doing. So it’s important to understand that, yes, the stock market leads the economy and, to some extent, reflects the economy…

VANEK SMITH: Yeah, they’re connected, like the dog and the…

BROWN: Yeah, the dog’s going walk in the general direction that the woman walks the dog. So the economy and the dog – or the economy the stock market are somewhat connected. But they do not look the same. They do not act the same even if they’re walking in the same direction.

Thanks to Stacey Vanek Smith and my old friend Cardiff Garcia for having me on the Planet Money show this week. My take on the recent market volatility here, embedded below:

You can read a transcript here:

See Stocks Run (NPR) 

Full Disclosure: Nothing on this site should ever be considered to be advice, research or an invitation to buy or sell any securities, please see my Terms & Conditions page for a full disclaimer.

What's been said:

Discussions found on the web
  1. My favorite analogy for stocks vs the economy – Financial Solutions commented on Nov 26

    […] from a new interview I did with NPR this week: BROWN: And I’m now going to give you my favorite analogy. So a woman is walking through Central Park, and she’s got a dog. What’s a very active kind of dog? VANEK SMITH: Oh, like a Jack Russell terrier or something like that? BROWN: Fine. Jack Russell Terrier is great. If you just looked at her, what is she doing? She’s taking normal steps. She’s… Source: https://thereformedbroker.com/2018/11/26/my-favorite-analogy-for-stocks-vs-the-economy/ […]

  2. Tuesday commented on Nov 26

    […] this insightful comparison for the stock market and the economy, c/o financial advisor Josh […]

  3. 2018’s last best hope commented on Nov 26

    […] this insightful comparison for the stock market and the economy, c/o financial advisor Josh […]

  4. 2019 preview: Winter is coming – Humble Student of the Markets commented on Dec 15

    […] Josh Brown had a terrific analogy for the stock market, though he could not claim to be the originator. He characterized the stock market as a untrained and hyperactive Jack Russell terrier leashed to its owner, the economy. Both move in the same general direction, but the dog`s movements are far more erratic and excitable. They don`t have the same temperament and tendencies, but over time, they move in the same direction. […]

Read this next.