A man and his signals

Once upon a time there was an egotistical man who sold subscriptions to a stock market research product based on the premise that his “signals” could tell people when to buy and sell. To get attention for his service, he railed regularly against the Wall Street establishment, whom he referred to derisively as outdated, hopeless “bagholders”. He had come out of the woodwork and shot to fame during the late stages of a grueling bear market, at a time when the American public was willing to believe that it was a good idea to rapidly buy and sell stocks on a daily basis. He’d sold a ton of subscriptions for his service and, for a little while, had a lot of people fooled – regular investors, professional traders and the media too. And then it all fell apart.

That man’s name was Joe Granville, that era was the late 1970’s, early 1980’s.

One of the benefits of studying the history of markets is that you quickly realize that everything is a rerun. We’ve seen it all before, though the people, places, products and circumstances change. The only thing an old trick needs to make a comeback is a new generation of investors, a fresh crop of naifs, willing to suspend disbelief and invest themselves in magical concepts.

At the peak of his popularity in 1981, Joe Granville had 16,000 active subscribers paying him between $250 and $3000 a year for his signals. He had single-handedly crashed the market by issuing a real-time sell alert to his subscribers via voice mail message in the middle of the night that January. People Magazine sent a reporter to debunk his ability to call the direction of stocks that April but he ended up charming her instead, garnering quite an advertisement for his genius in the process.

Central to Granville’s business model was the endless repetition about how his so-called “signals” enabled him to read the markets like no one else, buying and selling individual stocks based on a formula of different fundamental and technical metrics that he alone possessed. The prestigious Journal of Portfolio Management invited him in to discuss these signals with their quants to see if there was any merit to this systematic approach. Granville, the consummate showman, didn’t shy away. He sat there for hours laying out all of the various signals he used to divine the market’s message. The quants published the results of their backtesting and found that it was all gobbledygook. Granville just used the article to promote himself even further, the sheer fact that they were even talking about him was all he needed.

In the end, Granville’s signals were proven to be ineffective and the secular bull market that began in 1982 had left him behind. He never made the bullish turn, digging his heels in on a bearish call, and his subscriber base dwindled thereafter. He publicly announced that he’d failed because he had abandoned his old signals in lieu of new signals and, as such, he was going back to the original recipe. By then, it was already too late, the magic spell had worn off.

Mark Hulbert, who’s been studying the most well-known market-timers for more than three decades, eventually concluded that the Granville Letter was among the worst of these services over the long haul. If Granville did truly possess a system with merit at some point, it was clearly not a system that was built to endure.

The term “system” implies a mechanical approach to investing or trading, and perhaps there are some mechanical systems that are better than others. Unfortunately, investing will never be able to be reduced to sheer mechanics, at least not in the Newtonian sense of the word. In his book, Investing: The Last Liberal Art, author Robert Hagstrom explains that markets are not mechanical systems, in the end, and do not obey set laws as in physics. You can run one of Isaac Newton’s experiments one thousand times over and continue to get the same result – not so with markets comprised of millions of people and the infinite emotional variables that can never be reconciled on a spreadsheet. Markets are the opposite of mechanical, they are biological.

In mechanistic systems, small changes produce small effects, large changes produce large ones. It’s math. In a biological system, however, this construct cannot survive reality. Just as tiny changes in nature can produce massive mutations, so too can minor events have exponential impacts on financial markets. Thus, any “signals” one wants to employ must not only be able to identify significant events and pinpoint the timing of their occurrences, they must also be able to calculate the scale and scope of that event’s repercussions.

No one has a system or set of signals that can be relied upon to do that in all market environments.

No one ever has, no one ever will. Granville didn’t either.

Nor will any his modern-day successors.



Full Disclosure: Nothing on this site should ever be considered to be advice, research or an invitation to buy or sell any securities, please see my Terms & Conditions page for a full disclaimer.

What's been said:

Discussions found on the web
  1. خرید vpn commented on Feb 03

    وی پی ن آیفون

    I’m genuinely taking pleasure in the style and structure of your website. It’s a very effortless on the eyes which tends to make it significantly far more pleasurable for me to appear right here and visit more typically. Did you hire out a developer to…

  2. Belize motels commented on Feb 03

    Belize motels

    […]Here are some of the websites we advise for our visitors[…]

  3. گوگل adwords commented on Feb 04

    تبلیغات در صفحه اول گوگل

    Does your internet site have a contact page? I’m having a difficult time locating it but, I’d like to shoot you an e-mail. I’ve acquired some innovative concepts for your weblog you may be interested in listening to. Both way, great website and I searc…

  4. وی پی ان ایفون commented on Feb 04

    رفع ارور 1009

    We absolutely enjoy your weblog and locate practically all of your post’s to be what specifically I’m searching for. Does one particular supply guest writers to create material for you? I wouldn’t brain creating a publish or elaborating on a good deal…

  5. nebbia leginy commented on Feb 04

    nebbia leginy

    […]we came across a cool internet site that you just may love. Take a search for those who want[…]

  6. گوگل adwords commented on Feb 04

    تبلیغات در صفحه اول گوگل

    Hello there colleagues, how is all, and what you desire for to say about this post, in my check out its truly amazing made for me.

  7. Promotional Video Mauritius commented on Feb 04

    Promotional Video Mauritius

    […]usually posts some really exciting stuff like this. If you’re new to this site[…]

  8. کولر کارگاه commented on Feb 05

    خرید کولر صنعتی

    we arrived throughout a awesome world wide web site which you could appreciate. Just take a look when you want

  9. گوگل adwords commented on Feb 05

    تبلیغات در صفحه اول گوگل

    Hey! I know this is considerably off subject but I was wondering if you knew in which I could get a captcha plugin for my comment kind? I’m using the identical site platform as yours and I’m having problems discovering one particular? Many thanks a lot…

  10. گوگل adwords commented on Feb 06

    تبلیغات در صفحه اول گوگل

    We completely love your site and discover virtually all of your post’s to be what precisely I’m hunting for. Does a single offer you guest writers to write material for you? I would not head composing a publish or elaborating on a great deal of the top…

  11. خرید vpn برای ایفون 6 commented on Feb 06

    وی پی ن آیفون

    we prefer to honor lots of other net internet-internet sites on the net, even when they arent linked to us, by linking to them. Beneath are some webpages actually worth examining out

  12. دانلود hotspot shield برای ویندوز 7 commented on Feb 07

    رفع ارور 1009

    Greetings from Colorado! I’m bored to death at perform so I determined to browse your website on my iphone throughout lunch break. I truly like the information you supply right here and can’t hold out to take a search when I get house. I’m astonished a…

  13. تبلیغات گوگل commented on Feb 08

    تبلیغ در گوگل ادوردز

    listed here are some backlinks to world wide web internet pages that we link to considering that we come to feel they’re genuinely value visiting

  14. وی پی ان ایفون commented on Feb 08

    vpn ایفون

    Hey! I know this is fairly off matter but I was asking yourself which site system are you utilizing for this internet site? I’m receiving sick and exhausted of WordPress because I’ve experienced troubles with hackers and I’m searching at choices for an…

  15. novin marketing commented on Feb 09

    تبلیغ در گوگل ادوردز

    Do you have a spam problem on this site I also am a blogger, and I was wanting to know your circumstance we have created some good methods and we are seeking to swap approaches with other individuals, be positive to shoot me an e mail if fascinated.