T.I.N.A. (or the Seller’s Dilemma)

In 1901, steel magnate Andrew Carnegie sold his entire empire to JP Morgan for $480 million – a sum he had scribbled on a piece of paper and that Morgan did not haggle over.

After years of the kind of debilitating economic and political warfare it took to remain on top, Carnegie was finally done fighting, finally free to pursue his charitable endeavors on the other side of perpetual strife. With the stroke of a pen, Carnegie had become one of the wealthiest human beings in world history – that $480 million equates to a fortune of nearly $340 billion in today’s dollars, more than the net worth of Gates, Buffett and Carlos Slim combined.

But despite this amazing windfall, legend has it that before the deal-signing champagne bottle was even through Carnegie was wondering aloud about whether or not he’d made a good deal.  Should he have departed with his business and if so, was $480 million all he could have gotten out of the insatiable banker.

When discussing the possibility for continued rotation into stocks or the lofty levels of the S&P currently relative to recent years, it is important that we consider the Seller’s Dilemma.

Think of  a portfolio manager who is charged with earning a return for investors and can assume a moderate amount of risk. Let’s suppose he’s been running a portfolio of 25% US stocks, 25% international stocks and 50% fixed income (I can’t tell you how many portfolios have looked like this in real life for the last few years).  Now assume he reads a bunch of research and news and concludes that the market is due for a ten to twenty percent sell-off. And so he sells half his stocks, putting a quarter of his portfolio into wealth-destroying money market funds.

Days go by. Weeks. In the end, he buys back into the stock market again – maybe even buying some of his old positions back at slightly higher prices.

Why does he do this?

T.I.N.A. – There Is No Alternative.

The alternative he has is to own aburdly-priced bonds, buy highly volatile commodities, or go into less-liquid assets like real estate or private equity. In other words, for most PMs there is no alternative.

Think about the college endowments – the top 800 control $400 billion in investable assets. Among these 800 pools of professionally managed capital, US equities represent only 15%. In the meantime, hedge funds are their largest allocation bucket, 20% or $80 billion. The returns have been scary-bad, not even keeping up with the pace of the schools’ spending in the past year.  Yale University posted a loss of just under 1% in their last fiscal year ended June 30th. They have a laughable 6% allocation to US stocks. If you think this kind of thing isn’t being rethought all over the country as we speak, then you misunderstand the concept of career risk.

Now we’re all going to laugh at the T.I.N.A. acronym the next time the market gets bludgeoned – and it sure is overdue for a healthy beating one of these days. But the fact remains that much of the activity we’ll see across asset classes this year will be driven by exactly that lack of alternative, barring some other calamity we’re not yet aware of.

Seriously, what else are you going to do?

This is the reason stocks are now trading at an average multiple of 14 (vs the discounted one they may deserve given the lackluster economy). It’s the reason earnings shortfalls are being ignored in the aggregate and the reason even the most dour market watchers are coming out one after the other and admitting that yes, stocks are expensive, but not relative to alternatives.

Carnegie was faced with a “dilemma” of sorts – having sold out of his stake, now what?  A good dilemma to have, but still, it bothered him. The investment management pros I talk to are all feeling the same way each time they lighten up on stocks – now what do I do?




Full Disclosure: Nothing on this site should ever be considered to be advice, research or an invitation to buy or sell any securities, please see my Terms & Conditions page for a full disclaimer.

What's been said:

Discussions found on the web
  1. مه ساز commented on Aug 17

    مه پاش

    Hey there! I not too long ago saw your site and I certainly appreciate it. I adore to talk about omega xl at times. Excellent to be close to, many thanks a lot!

  2. قیمت اسکوتر برقی commented on Aug 19


    here are some hyperlinks to web internet pages that we hyperlink to since we feel they’re genuinely value visiting

  3. خرید vpn commented on Aug 19

    vpn ایفون

    below are some hyperlinks to websites that we url to since we think they’re value checking out

  4. mcat total score commented on Aug 19

    mcat total score

    […]Every the moment inside a even though we opt for blogs that we study. Listed beneath are the most recent sites that we decide on […]

  5. Adam and Eve Box commented on Aug 20

    Adam and Eve Box

    […]check below, are some absolutely unrelated sites to ours, nonetheless, they are most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  6. judi online commented on Aug 20

    judi online

    […]just beneath, are various totally not connected web sites to ours, having said that, they’re certainly really worth going over[…]

  7. air ticket commented on Aug 21

    air ticket

    […]Sites of interest we have a link to[…]

  8. Burberry commented on Aug 23


    […]one of our visitors not long ago recommended the following website[…]

  9. lesvianas commented on Aug 24


    […]Here is a good Weblog You may Find Fascinating that we Encourage You[…]

  10. دوربین مدار بسته commented on Aug 24


    If you are heading for most excellent contents like myself, just go to see this internet site daily because it presents characteristic contents, thanks

  11. pc app for windows 8 commented on Aug 25

    pc app for windows 8

    […]we like to honor several other web sites on the net, even though they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages really worth checking out[…]

  12. coupon deals commented on Aug 27

    coupon deals

    […]Every when in a although we opt for blogs that we study. Listed beneath would be the most current web pages that we choose […]

  13. Adult SEO commented on Aug 27

    Adult SEO

    […]check below, are some absolutely unrelated internet sites to ours, nonetheless, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  14. Fendi commented on Aug 28


    […]Here are a number of the internet sites we advise for our visitors[…]

Read this next.