Fired Managers Outperform Hired Managers

Just when I think I can no longer be shocked by a statistic about the bad behavior of investors and its consequences, a new one comes running across my path that leaves me completely floored.

The latest stat I’ve come across concerns the hiring and firing of managers because of three-year track records, a exercise in faildom if ever there was one. The executive summary for this kind of thing goes like this: “Wow, look at those returns for the last three years! I would have made a lot more money if I was with that fund, I’m not going to miss out over the next three years!” The old manager you’re working with, who is of course a complete idiot to you now, gets fired and the new hotshot who’s been crushing it gets hired.

And then, of course, mean reversion sets in and you ended up firing the old guy at the worst moment you possibly could have, and then doubly screwing yourself by handing that money over to the new guy just as he’s statistically poised to do even worse.

Many investors do this sort of thing again and again, as though on a treadmill. It’s understandable, as people succumb to both the Recency Bias and the Hot Hand Fallacy all at once. Usually, it’s the people who pay too much attention to the day-to-day fluctuations of their investments that are most susceptible. By focusing on what’s been happening lately, an extrapolative picture forms in their mind in which they envision a continuing trend of unhappiness with one strategy and a grass-is-greener fantasy about some other approach. At a certain point, they just can’t take it anymore and they make the switch.

There’s a great George Orwell quote that I think is applicable here: Whoever is winning at the moment will always seem to be invincible.” 

My friend Meb Faber talked about this years ago during a spate of underperformance for an old strategy of his. He totally nailed it with this graphic, which juxtaposes the strategy against a plain vanilla buy-and-hold, the thing everyone is relentlessly judged against in a bull market:


The bottom line is that everyone is “long-term oriented” and comfortable with the tradeoffs of investing up to a point. And then we break. Some have a higher tolerance and more patience for a rough patch than others, but in the end, human nature usually wins out.

Anyway, the harm done by firing underperforming managers and hiring perceived outperformers hasn’t been extensively documented, even if the lack of persistence of performance has. Below, we’ll take a look at this phenomenon thanks to a chart posted by the team at GestaltU. In an epic post from January of 2013, the blog makes the point that three-year track records are meaningless and can even do more harm than good when investors react to them.

My favorite illustration of this is in the form of a manager switch study they cite with data from the Employee Benefit Research Institute…

Chart 5. clearly illustrates the impact of this phenomenon in the pension space. The grey bars represent the average annualized performance of terminated managers in the three years prior to, and three years subsequent to, their termination. The white bars represent the performance of replacement managers in the same years. Clearly institutions are hiring managers with exceptional historical track records over trailing 3 year periods, and firing managers with poor track records. The joke is on the institutions, however, since on average the fired managers go on to outperform the hired managers over the subsequent 1, 2, and 3 year periods!

Chart 5. Excess returns to terminated and newly hired managers in the 3 years prior to, and subsequent to, termination

Screen Shot 2014-08-07 at 10.24.54 AM

Josh here – Yes, I was surprised by this. But upon reflection, it makes total sense.

It shouldn’t be surprising to see the firms that were fired for trailing three-year performance (gray) pull ahead of the new managers that were added (white) if you understand how powerful the role of luck is in investment returns and how inexorable mean reversion can be in a complex system like the stock market. The more skilled the total pool of managers is, the more quirky the results will be as a result. With so many skilled managers on The Street all trying to do the same thing, it shouldn’t come as a shock that randomness plays such a big part in the end result. Michael Mauboussin has written and spoken extensively on this paradox of skill, check it out here.

Anyway, the interesting thing is that this behavior is not limited to the individual investor. Wholesalers are constantly pitching advisors like myself on funds that have done really well recently, family offices are constantly taking meetings with the sexiest fund managers of the moment, magazines are still blaring the old “Five Hot Funds You Need To Check Out Now” right from the cover. And even the most sophisticated among us aren’t immune – as the above study concerns institutional investors who hire and fire managers for trillions of dollars held in pension funds.

GestaltU reminds us that even an institutional investment fund is run by people, after all, and the human element is tough to eradicate.

Read Also:

Why Are You Outperforming? Why Are You Underperforming? (Meb Faber Research)

Persistence is a Killer (TRB)

Alpha and the Paradox of Skill (Credit Suisse)




Full Disclosure: Nothing on this site should ever be considered to be advice, research or an invitation to buy or sell any securities, please see my Terms & Conditions page for a full disclaimer.

What's been said:

Discussions found on the web
  1. Cock ring commented on Aug 11

    Cock ring

    […]very couple of websites that transpire to be detailed beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly very well worth checking out[…]

  2. Nipple Toys commented on Aug 11

    Nipple Toys

    […]very few web-sites that happen to become in depth beneath, from our point of view are undoubtedly properly really worth checking out[…]

  3. bangal ka jadu commented on Aug 12

    bangal ka jadu

    […]Wonderful story, reckoned we could combine a couple of unrelated information, nonetheless seriously really worth taking a look, whoa did 1 study about Mid East has got additional problerms at the same time […]

  4. Mofongo commented on Aug 12


    […]very couple of web-sites that transpire to be in depth below, from our point of view are undoubtedly nicely worth checking out[…]

  5. bangal ka jadu commented on Aug 13

    bangal ka jadu

    […]always a major fan of linking to bloggers that I appreciate but really don’t get quite a bit of link adore from[…]

  6. driving tips commented on Aug 13

    driving tips

    […]that may be the end of this report. Right here you will locate some web pages that we feel you will value, just click the links over[…]

  7. Master karate pants commented on Aug 13

    Master karate pants

    […]although internet sites we backlink to beneath are considerably not connected to ours, we feel they are truly really worth a go by, so have a look[…]

  8. Best Rabbit Vibrator commented on Aug 14

    Best Rabbit Vibrator

    […]we came across a cool internet site that you may well enjoy. Take a search when you want[…]

  9. male mastubator toy commented on Aug 14

    male mastubator toy

    […]the time to study or take a look at the material or web pages we have linked to beneath the[…]

  10. massage vibrator commented on Aug 15

    massage vibrator

    […]here are some links to web sites that we link to simply because we think they may be worth visiting[…]

  11. couples sex toy commented on Aug 15

    couples sex toy

    […]check beneath, are some completely unrelated web sites to ours, however, they’re most trustworthy sources that we use[…]

  12. dong commented on Aug 15


    […]that could be the end of this article. Here you’ll obtain some websites that we assume you’ll enjoy, just click the links over[…]

  13. adam and eve commented on Aug 16

    adam and eve

    […]just beneath, are various entirely not connected internet sites to ours, even so, they are certainly worth going over[…]

  14. مشاوره با وکیل commented on Aug 16

    وکیل پایه یک و مشاور حقوقی شما

    It¡¦s in truth a great and valuable piece of info. I¡¦m content that you just shared this helpful info with us. Please hold us up to date like this. Thanks for sharing.

  15. gay lubes commented on Aug 16

    gay lubes

    […]please pay a visit to the internet sites we adhere to, which includes this one, as it represents our picks through the web[…]