“A camel sneezed in Dubai and the immediate reaction was a flight…TOTHE US DOLLAR“
– TRB
I am not making a directional call on gold here or offering any kind of advice, but I am going to disabuse many who read this of a very foolish notion:
Gold is no longer any kind of “Safe Haven”. Those days ended when the 38th gold ETF came public and the 900th commercial for gold coins ran on Fox News during the Glenn Beck Paranoid Lunatics Anonymous Hour.
Don’t get it twisted – gold is now the quintessential risk trade, moving in tandem with risk appetites and the pursuit of momentum by investors around the world.
Don’t believe me? How about this…during Thanksgiving week, when half of the country’s traders were away from their screens, you got your proof:
A camel sneezed in Dubai and the immediate reaction was a flight – TOTHE US DOLLAR. Gold was smacked down immediately, albeit briefly, as the HOT MONEY came flying out of it right alongside crude oil, tech stocks and junk bonds.
For that brief moment when the financial world teetered on the edge of a possible panic, the only green on the screen was in the greenback. When there was real fear, the first reaction was to flee the precious metals, not to buy them, as would be consistent with an asset class that was truly a safe haven.
You want to “play gold” or pat yourself on the back for owning hard assets, be my guest, it certainly is working right now. That said, don’t tell me with a straight face that you’re in it “for the safety”.
We learned the other day just how disingenuous that statement truly is.
Full Disclosure: Nothing on this site should ever be construed as research, advice or an invitation to buy or sell any securities, please see my Terms & Conditions page for a full disclaimer.
[…] Also, gold fundamentals seem in place to drive its value much higher in the long run. That said, The Reformed Broker’s hypothesis is interesting enough to demand consideration for the short […]
[…] Also, gold fundamentals seem in place to drive its value much higher in the long run. That said, The Reformed Broker’s hypothesis is interesting enough to demand consideration for the short […]
[…] the perceptions of what safe haven assets are. What bounced on the news? The U.S. dollar (UUP). What “safe haven” sold off? Gold (GLD). I understand the appeal of gold, but am skeptical of its ability to be a true store of value in […]
[…] the perceptions of what safe haven assets are. What bounced on the news? The U.S. dollar (UUP). What “safe haven” sold off? Gold (GLD). I understand the appeal of gold, but am skeptical of its ability to be a true store of value in […]
I’m a New York City-based financial advisor at Ritholtz Wealth Management LLC. I help people invest and manage portfolios for them. For disclosure information please see here.
Get a Full Investor Curriculum: Join The Book List
Every month you'll receive 3-4 book suggestions--chosen by hand from more than 1,000 books. You'll also receive an extensive curriculum (books, articles, papers, videos) in PDF form right away.
[…] in tandem with risk appetites and the pursuit of momentum by investors around the world.” (The Reformed Broker also […]
[…] in tandem with risk appetites and the pursuit of momentum by investors around the world.” (The Reformed Broker also […]
[…] http://thereformedbroker.com/2009/12/02/public-service-announcement-gold-is-now-the-risk-trade-not-t… […]
[…] http://thereformedbroker.com/2009/12/02/public-service-announcement-gold-is-now-the-risk-trade-not-t… […]
[…] Also, gold fundamentals seem in place to drive its value much higher in the long run. That said, The Reformed Broker’s hypothesis is interesting enough to demand consideration for the short […]
[…] Also, gold fundamentals seem in place to drive its value much higher in the long run. That said, The Reformed Broker’s hypothesis is interesting enough to demand consideration for the short […]
What will be the safe haven if the U.S. is the target of a terrorist attack?
TRB: go to nebraska in that case. its where they stashed George W on 9/11
What will be the safe haven if the U.S. is the target of a terrorist attack?
TRB: go to nebraska in that case. its where they stashed George W on 9/11
The rise of the dollar during the Dubai shock could be caused by an unwind of dollar carry trades ;).
However I agree that gold is not a safe haven, nor an investment. Buying gold is nowadays highly speculative.
The rise of the dollar during the Dubai shock could be caused by an unwind of dollar carry trades ;).
However I agree that gold is not a safe haven, nor an investment. Buying gold is nowadays highly speculative.
[…] in tandem with risk appetites and the pursuit of momentum by investors around the world.” (The Reformed Broker also […]
[…] in tandem with risk appetites and the pursuit of momentum by investors around the world.” (The Reformed Broker also […]
[…] the perceptions of what safe haven assets are. What bounced on the news? The U.S. dollar (UUP). What “safe haven” sold off? Gold (GLD). I understand the appeal of gold, but am skeptical of its ability to be a true store of value in […]
[…] the perceptions of what safe haven assets are. What bounced on the news? The U.S. dollar (UUP). What “safe haven” sold off? Gold (GLD). I understand the appeal of gold, but am skeptical of its ability to be a true store of value in […]
… [Trackback]
[…] Read More on to that Topic: thereformedbroker.com/2009/12/02/public-service-announcement-gold-is-now-the-risk-trade-not-the-safe-haven/ […]